The biggest difference between ActiveCollab and Basecamp lies in purpose, and to be exact, in scope of functionality. While one is a superb administrator, the other is the engine room of your entire organization.
In essence, both are project management tools, however, one offers a set of capabilities that go way beyond traditional project management platforms.
They’re both rock-solid products in their own right and within the right context. But if you’re a service business (like say a marketing agency, consultancy or software development firm), chances are you’ll need and want “the engine room”. Keep reading to find out why.
In a nutshell: ActiveCollab runs your agency, Basecamp organizes your projects
| Segment | ActiveCollab | Basecamp |
|---|---|---|
| Setup & Onboarding | Full-featured system, clean design & intuitive setup lets you create projects instantly | Clean & simple interface, lets you create projects and to-dos with minimal set up |
| End-to-end client project management | Complete hub including quotes, projects, collaboration, time tracking, invoicing and payment – all connected | Task and communication hub with basic project management, collaboration & time tracking |
| Collaboration (internal + external) | Internal & external collaboration, unlimited clients, granular permissions, client profiles & financial transparency options | Internal & external collaboration, unlimited clients, limited access controls |
| Workload Management | Real-time workload view, resource management & capacity planning ideal for service workflows | No native workload or resource management features but can be added through integrations |
| Dashboards & Reporting | Detailed project, time, budget and profitability reports & custom dashboards | Limited reporting with progress updates, activity feeds and Hill Charts |
| Ideal Users | Agencies, consultancies and service business after full client and agency lifecycle management | Any team looking for a simple, communication and task management-first tool without multiple functions |
| Value for money | High value for agencies wanting one platform to connect & cover all their needs | Affordable choice for all team types looking for streamlined collaboration & task management |
The nutshell is that these two tools have completely different user intents.
If you want a basic tool to organize your team and projects, Basecamp will work just fine.
But if you want a tool that’s going to do all that and tell you:
- Which projects are money makers, and which are money burners
- Which team members are star performers and which are underutilized
- What your profit margins are, and where business growth potential lies
… then you’ll want ActiveCollab.
Basecamp is a simple platform for basic project management with solid team collaboration features. And if you jump on their website, you’ll see they openly state, “small businesses are their favorite businesses”. So their product is tailored to this core segment.
ActiveCollab, on the other hand, with its tailor-made platform designed for “growing service businesses” whether they be small or medium teams, is targeting a completely different set of needs.
It’s not just a project and task management tool – it’s a powerful, all-encompassing workspace for agencies and consultancies that want to integrate all their projects, clients and business operations into one system.
It combines robust project management with client service features, and then goes a step further letting you track business profitability and optimize resource allocations.
Now we get that this sounds like a lot, and that’s because it is. Service businesses are complex ecosystems. Every agency owner and their dog knows that. They also know how difficult it is to run a profitable agency.
They know that without the right data, they’ll struggle to make smart pricing and resource management decisions which puts their business at risk.
And that’s not the way high-flying agencies roll.
Booming agencies and service businesses yearn to earn and deliver more. We uncover what more looks like as we go through all the things that help founders keep a pulse on the health of their entire business operation.
ActiveCollab is end-to-end client projects, Basecamp centres on project collaboration
ActiveCollab is a true end-to-end client project management system. You can go from sending a client quote, to turning it into a live project, to invoicing and receiving payment – all in one place.
Every step is connected. When your team logs time against billable and unbillable tasks using the built-in tracker, those hours automatically roll into the project’s budget. With a few clicks, that data can be turned into an invoice and sent directly to the client.
For agencies where tasks are time, time are resources and both are money, this kind of transparency and cohesion is invaluable.
Beyond billing, ActiveCollab equips you with advanced task management features. You can create tasks and subtasks, and set automatic dependencies that adjust around weekends and team availability. It’s a tool that scales with complex client timelines, offering visibility and control across every layer of a project.
But the point where ActiveCollab really comes out on top is in the client lifecycle. It lets you create client profiles, set access permissions and even choose to share tracked time and expenses for full billing transparency. Because invoicing and payments happen in the same system you use to manage work, you have a seamless loop from planning to profit.
It’s a system that lets you choose your level and extent of client interaction. You can do simple approvals or open the door to full collaboration on project tasks.
So ActiveCollab lets you unite and harmonize every aspect that goes into a client project.
Basecamp on the other hand excels as a lightweight collaboration tool. It simplifies task lists and team communication, but doesn’t offer the flexibility of advanced permission settings that ActiveCollab does such as creating new projects and tasks.
The other thing you don’t get with Basecamp is the integrated project financials and client billing which is what makes ActiveCollab a true end-to-end platform.
ActiveCollab covers workload, resources & capacity, Basecamp needs integrations
Service businesses live and die by their team’s time and resource management. Take on more work than your team can handle and you’re heading down the road to burnout. Leave your team with too much free time on their hands and your overheads will blowout.
ActiveCollab helps you prevent both with a bird's-eye-view of your team’s workload, real-time.
Start by customizing and setting each individual’s daily capacity and then simply watch the workloads to achieve the perfect balance. When someone is overbooked, use the drag and drop feature to move tasks between team members.
With time-off management, you’ll also see what an achievable due date is for a task so you never set a project or team up for failure.
If productivity and resource management are a sore spot for your agency, you can overcome it with ActiveCollab by proactively managing resource allocation and capacity.
Essentially, what ActiveCollab’s workload and resource management feature does is it acts like your business’s work traffic controller. It brings potential hazards to your attention so you can plan realistic and obtainable project timelines. No more overworked teams, and no more broken client promises.
Basecamp on the other hand doesn’t come with any native resource or workload management features. So managing your team’s time doesn’t go beyond basic allocation and manually referencing the number of items on their to-do lists. However, Basecamp does offer third-party integrations, which you can connect to better understand and manage your team’s capacity.
ActiveCollab monitors budgets & profitability, Basecamp relies on third-party tools
Budgeting and profitability are top of mind for every service-business owner. That’s why the founders of ActiveCollab have evolved the platform so it steps in to be a bit like your agency’s virtual CFO.
For every project that you set up in ActiveCollab, you can choose between several budget types, whether it be fixed-fee, monthly retainer or hourly, plus expenses. You can also set internal hourly rates for your team and link with their capacity and utilization to get a clear understanding of margin per project.
Another big perk is the ability to set multiple budget alerts. Choose a threshold (say 70%) and the tool will send out a warning notification when you're nearing the specified budget spend.
Also, with a real-time overview dashboard for every project you create, you can monitor budget spend and project progress daily, and step in to manage overruns before it’s too late.
This project budgeting pain point is another area where Basecamp doesn’t offer any built-in solutions. It’s a great core project task management system but for budgeting insights you’ll once again need to turn to third-party apps that are more specialized in this areas.
ActiveCollab collates business health & productivity data, Basecamp has limited reporting
Most agency or consultancy business founders need to go beyond individual project financials. They want to grasp the overall health of their business and the quality of their client relationships.
The questions they’ll ask and which ActiveCollab’s reports and dashboards can provide answers to include:
- Are client projects generally tracking on schedule and on budget overall?
- What is our current profit margin and has it improved when compared to last year?
- What are the team’s productivity trends?
- How accurate are our time and budget estimates?
By creating custom reports or using the ready-made dashboards on the platform, you can see things like total tracked hours per employee, cashflow health and outstanding invoices, as well as profitability across all projects over a period.
You can configure dashboards to include metrics that matter to you and export reports to share data with the leadership team and pull key insights.
Use that data to make better-informed decisions on the type of client projects you should focus on, and to guide your recruitment plans. It basically lets you come up with a business growth strategy that’s backed by your business trends instead of broad industry trends and gut guesses.
When it comes to reports in Basecamp, it does offer progress reports that will take you as far as ensuring tasks don’t fall behind. But in terms of comprehensive business dashboards, that’s something you’ll have to either manually create outside of the tool or connect to another external app via integrations.
ActiveCollab vs Basecamp – Which one is easier for your team to adopt?
A tool can have all the bells and whistles that your imagination can dream up but if the system is clunky and hard to learn it will be useless.
That’s why the usability and design of a tool is what ultimately leads to the final decision.
ActiveCollab achieves the perfect balance between usability and robustness. It has all the features neatly set up in one work platform that’s both functional and intuitive. You can choose the number of features you use depending on your needs.
The core features of ActiveCollab will feel familiar to anyone who’s used project management tools like Asana or Trello.
Basecamp is ultra-simple but it’s centred around project task management, rather than full-scale agency, client and projects. Not having all these operations centralized in one tool can make it difficult for businesses to get a comprehensive picture of their entire operation. While this may not matter for smaller agencies that might be just starting out, it will matter for agencies planning to scale. Unless you connect to multiple third-party tools to build out the core Basecamp platform, chances are you’ll outgrow the system at some point.
Another thing to keep in mind is the layout. Because it’s different from traditional project management tools, it might feel foreign to some users, so it may take some time to get used to. Its design is similar to ClickUp and Teamwork.
When you look at price and value, which is better?
Now for the final weigh-in. When you compare what you get for the dollars, pounds or euros you cough-up for the tool, which one wins out?
We’ve looked at both. We’ve crunched the numbers, and here’s what we found:
- For teams of 3 or less: ActiveCollab costs less and you get more features than Basecamp’s free plan.
- For teams of 10: ActiveCollab (yet again) costs less and continues to offer more capabilities.
- For teams of ~25: ActiveCollab’s highest-tier plan with all the productivity, resource and capacity planning, budgeting and profitability features ends up costing a measly $1 more.
- For teams of 25+: ActiveCollab will cost more than Basecamp but when you’re a service business with this many employees, chances are you’ll need all the planning and profitability features Basecamp doesn’t offer anyway.
Now we’re not being biased. We get that this is a comparison article on ActiveCollab’s blog so of course we’re going to do our best to position ourselves in the limelight. But that’s because we stand behind each and every claim in this article.
ActiveCollab is tailor-made for service businesses that want more out of their project management tool.
They want one workspace, one system and one source of truth for their entire business operation. They want a cohesive, all-in-one software platform that will help them scale in the space that promises profits. Not just organize tasks and deliver work on time.
ActiveCollab to end overworked teams and underperforming projects
Choosing between ActiveCollab and Basecamp comes down to what your business needs vs. what you can get by with. If you’re a small team looking for basic project management through lists and task coordination, Basecamp will serve you just fine. But if you’re a service business, juggling multiple client projects and are keen to scale profitability without overworking your people, then ActiveCollab is where we’d go.
What you get with ActiveColla is a jam-packed, all-in-one platform that’s easy to learn and use. Built for agencies, consultancies, startups and firms it’s for businesses that want more than surface-level project management. It goes deeper, letting you uncover key performance and profitability trends within your operation.
If you want to bill accurately, plan capacity smartly, and nurture and manage client relationships in one unified tool, you’ll get that with ActiveCollab. With interconnected features, the tool streamlines every process that goes into a client project. Time tracking feeds into workloads and budget. Workloads let you do capacity planning so you prevent burnout. And budgets link into profitability so you understand exactly which clients are your most priced money-earners.
While Basecamp keeps things simple, ActiveCollab actively supports your business’s operational health.
So if you’re tired of paying for multiple tools that don’t speak to each other, and if you’re wondering where your team’s hours, and your margins are going, it might be time to try ActiveCollab.
Sign up for our 14-day free trial or book a demo with our head of sales to walk you through the platform that’s about to transform your service business’s operations!
Get ready to see your productivity and profitability start climbing!
---
P.S. Found some of the data incorrect? We enjoy competitive edge, but always want to make sure that data is 100% accurate, so in case we missed something (or you're not exactly sure about some feature comparison), please do not hesitate to contact us and someone will be with you ASAP!
